Greensburg — Around 11 a.m. on May 17, Courtney Gail Tressler, 25, allegedly placed her disabled son, Payton Wesley Ettinger, 4, into his crib for a nap. He would never wake up. On Wednesday, Aug. 18, more than three months after Payton’s death, Tressler was arrested on charges of neglect of a dependent, a Class A felony, and reckless homicide, a Class C felony. She posted the $15,000 bond and was released. The investigation into Payton’s death began with a 911 call received by the Decatur County Sheriff’s Department at 3:23 p.m. Decatur County EMS arrived at 307 E. Meadow Drive within a minute and placed to a call to Greensburg dispatch requesting the coroner at 3:25 p.m., according to police blotter records. According to the probable cause affidavit filed in Decatur County Circuit Court, Greensburg Police Department detectives arrived shortly after and Coroner Doug Banks took the body into custody. After an extensive autopsy and tests that took until Aug. 13 to complete, it was determined Payton died due to “malnutrition and dehydration,” according to the affidavit. Banks said he would not comment further on the autopsy results beyond what was stated in the affidavit. However, the pathologist’s findings, the report states, showed “no significant amount of food in the child’s intestines or stomach” and “the physical appearance of the child’s body clearly showed profound malnutrition and no body fat on the child’s body... (the) skin on his face was drawn tightly against his skull and face bones with obvious emaciation.” The 4-year-old weighed 12 pounds at the time of his death. This is not the first time in Payton’s short life one of his parents has been accused of harming him. Payton was born in Traverse City, Mich., on Oct. 31, 2005. In his first two months of life, according to records from the 13th Judicial Circuit Court of Grand Traverse County (Mich.), Martin Ettinger repeatedly abused his infant son. Ettinger was convicted of first degree child abuse on April 28, 2006, and is currently serving a 15-year prison term. Payton was left brain damaged, according to the current affidavit, and suffered developmental disabilities. On May 18, GPD detectives interviewed Courtney Tressler as well as her husband and Payton’s step-father, Greg Tressler. In that interview, according to the affidavit, she told police she “intended to take Payton to the hospital” two days before his death because she had noticed the child was losing weight. However, she told detectives personal finances caused her to delay the trip. She also stated she had taken Payton to a children’s clinic in Michigan in 2009 and she had twice applied, but was denied, for Medicaid assistance. According to the affidavit, however, Tressler had not taken Payton to the hospital since November 2006. A review of the records from the clinic in Michigan showed Payton “achieved a body weight of 17 pounds, three ounces” in his first year and was 16 pounds, five ounces in July 2006. The affidavit also states that upon perusal of DCS records, Tressler never attempted to apply for Medicaid. While she also told police she could not afford a trip to the hospital, “she went twice to Decatur County Memorial Hospital for her own personal medical reasons” on May 19. The GPD and Decatur County Prosecutor’s Office are not commenting any further on the case beyond the probable cause affidavit. GPD Chief Brian Heaton said the facts of the case were in the report. “I’ve been instructed not to comment any further,” Heaton said. Prosecutor Bill Smith also denied comment. While Tressler was charged, Smith did not comment on the reasons for the absence of charges for Greg Tressler, noting he was not Payton’s legal guardian and the law is “complicated.”
Local News
- Local News
-
- Drivers need to pay attention
- Food and Growers Association to host seminar Feb. 11
-
Indy hosts world's biggest football party
A wild and record-setting Super Bowl week was capped Sunday with the New York Giants winning their fourth title game. But the host city of Indianapolis was a winner as well.
-
BHS student doing her part
-
BHS graduate's work on display
-
NFL Play 60 Kids Day gets them moving
-
SLIDESHOW: Super Bowl Media Day
Thousands of fans and members of the press turned out in Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis for Super Bowl XLVI Media Day.
-
Indy draws on super effort to overcome skeptics
Leaders of Indiana's capital city spent years gussying up their downtown to prepare for Super Bowl XLVI -- by building big sports and convention venues and luring nice hotels, popular restaurants and a four-story shopping mall.
-
Zip line: An experience to remember
- Excitement builds for big game
- More Local News Headlines







